Benefit's BrowZings! I seirously swear by that stuff.
I have to go with Benefit Browzings too....its the only one ive used but it does the job and lasts forever!
Has anyone tried Tarte waterproof brow mousse? I've been planning on trying it. It has great reviews.
I use a covergirl pencil in "mink" then eyeshadow in whatever color my hair is at the moment (right now its red), then set my brows with a translucent face powder. I think that the mix of pencil then powder helps my brow color stay put. My eyebrows dont fade or anything, even after going to the gym unless i wipe my face.
I have always just used eyebrow pencils to fill in my brows. Nowadays I use MAC. But I must absolutely check out Brow Zings.
Make up for ever's Aqua Brow... it's a high pigmented & waterproof gel that you apply with a stiff angle brush. You can be subtle with small brush strokes or draw a bold line & it gives you that perfect "tattooed" on eyebrow.
That stuff last forever (you only need a teenyyy tiny bit !) & IS completely sweat & water proof : even under water you still will have your brows on ! Believe me !
Personnaly I use plain matte reddish brown eyeshadow to fill in mine for a daily basis & I never had troubles with it wearing off during the day :)
During one of her makeup classes, Micheline advised me to use Anastasia brow powder. I love it, and it stays put! The biggest bonus was that it's the first color I've found to match my ash blonde hair without looking too orangey. They have some other brow products, too, including some kind of a setting gel. Look for it at Ulta or Sephora.