I finally found a picture of it. The dress I'm wearing in my current profile picture is PUGs Mila dress from 2005, I believe. I need to take more pictures of myself in it but in the meantime here's Amie Decker in the Mila off the website from back in the day.
Gorgeous dress, gorgeous Amie!
And now here's my arm wearing it:
I'm not gonna lie. Pretty!
More pictures to come with my current hair :)